Gene Tierney Belle Starr

Randolph Scott Sam Starr

Dana Andrews Thomas Crail

Shepperd Strudwick Ed Shirley

Elizabeth Patterson Sarah

Chill Wills Blue Duck

Louise Beavers Mammy Lou

Olin Howland Jasper Trench

Paul E. Burns Sergeant

Joe Sawyer John Cole

Joe Downing Jim Cole

Howard Hickman Colonel Thornton

Charles Trowbridge Colonel Bright

James Flavin Sergeant

Charles Middleton Carpetbagger

Herbert Ashley Jailer (uncredited)

Hooper Atchley Carpetbagger

Matthew Beard Young Jake (uncredited)

Hugh Chapman Tench's Son (uncredited)

Davison Clark Bartender (uncredited)

Mary Currier Dressmaker (uncredited)

Franklyn Farnum Barfly (uncredited)

Edward Fielding Undetermined Secondary Role (uncredited)

Avanelle Harris Dressed-up Freed Slave (uncredited)

Dolores Hurlic Jake's Granddaughter (uncredited)

Mae Marsh Preacher's Wife (uncredited)

Kermit Maynard Union Officer (uncredited)

George Melford Preacher (uncredited)

Juanita Moore Dressed-up Freed Slave (uncredited)

Adrian Morris Major Grail's Orderly (uncredited)

Clarence Muse Bootblack in Saloon (uncredited)

George H. Reed Old Jake (uncredited)

Clinton Rosemond Black Man on Bench (uncredited)

Elena Verdugo Young Girl (uncredited)

Billy Wayne Soldier (uncredited)

Cecil Weston Mother (uncredited)

Norman Willis Union Corporal (uncredited)